DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.18203/2349-2902.isj20221430

The importance of simulation training in surgical sciences

Bernardo A. Fernández-Reyes, Ana K. Flores-González, Luis Adrian Alvarez-Lozada, Juventino T. Guerrero-Zertuche, Francisco J. Arrambide-Garza, Xavier G. Quiroz-Perales, Alejandro Quiroga-Garza, Rodrigo E. Elizondo-Omaña, Santos Guzmán-López

Abstract


Simulators have been used throughout history to practice complicated procedures before performing them on human beings. The earliest simulation attempts were in cadavers. Donor bodies are still used for teaching and research but involve costly infrastructure, ethical and legal issues, as well as animal models. Training models need to be purposefully designed. These can be physical models, 3-D printed, simulators with virtual reality, augmented reality, or a hybrid simulation. The inert model is an alternative for animal tissue models, based on a trial-and-error method, the learning curve is approximately 65 procedures for a laparoscopist. Simulations models with virtual and augmented reality have shown that can reduce the time of practitioners with experience in laparoscopy, with an approximate reduction of 30 to 58%. Video-based learning method has been adopted in recent years but has shown to be less effective than hand-on learning using a simulator. Simulation can be involved to simulate specific scenarios, recreate simulated trauma patients, help develop a doctor-patient relationship and prepare complex approaches. Patient safety concerns call for the need to train medical personnel in simulated settings to reduce cost and patient morbidity because the ability to acquire surgical skills requires consistent practice. Simulation represents ideal teaching methods to optimize the knowledge and skill of residents before they are entrusted with procedures with real patients.


Keywords


Simulation, Surgical simulation, Surgical training, Surgical education

Full Text:

PDF

References


Rehder R, Abd-El-Barr M, Hooten K, Weinstock P, Madsen JR, Cohen AR. The role of simulation in neurosurgery. Child's Nervous System. 2016;32(1):43-54.

Quiroga-Garza A, Reyes-Hernández CG, Zarate-Garza PP, Esparza-Hernández CN, Gutierrez-de la OJ, de la Fuente-Villarreal D, et al. Willingness toward organ and body donation among anatomy professors and students in Mexico. Anatomical Sciences Education. 2017;10(6):589-97.

Salinas-Alvarez Y, Quiroga-Garza A, Martinez-Garza JH, Jacobo-Baca G, Zarate-Garza PP, Rodríguez-Alanís KV, et al. Mexican Educators Survey on Anatomical Sciences Education and a Review of World Tendencies. Anatomical Sciences Education. 2021;14(4):471-81.

Quiroga-Garza A, Delgado-Brito M, Bazaldúa-Cruz JJ, Villarreal-Silva E, Velázquez-Gauna SE, Elizondo-Omaña RE, et al. Nuevo modelo microquirúrgico para el estudio de la respuesta morfológica adaptativa de injertos venosos [New microsurgical model for the study of the morphological adaptative response of venous grafts]. Revista de investigacion clinica; organo del Hospital de Enfermedades de la Nutricion. 2011;63(4):399-406.

Velázquez Gauna SE, Soto Domínguez A, Quiroga Garza A, Reyes Hernández CG, Chávez Reyes A, Morales Avalos R, et al. Histomorphometric and immunohistochemical study of early adaptative response of the vascular wall in a termino-terminal microsurgical model of femoral vessels in Wistar rat. Int J Morphol. 2017;35(2):479-87.

De la Garza-Castro O, Sánchez-González SG, De La Garza-Pineda O, Espinosa-Uribe AG, Quiroga-Garza A, Elizondo-Omaña RE, et al. Dermatology surgery training in a live animal model. J Morphol Sci. 2018;35(03):187-90.

Gonzalez-Navarro AR, Quiroga-Garza A, Acosta-Luna AS, Salinas-Alvarez Y, Martinez-Garza JH, de la Garza-Castro O, et al. Comparison of suturing models: the effect on perception of basic surgical skills. BMC Med Educ. 2021;21(1):250.

Krebs C, Quiroga-Garza A, Pennefather P, Elizondo-Omaña RE. Ethics behind technology-enhanced medical education and the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic. Eur J Anat. 2021;25(4):515-22.

Muñoz-Leija MA, Paul BR, Shi G, Dixit I, Quiroga-Garza A, Elizondo-Omaña RE, et al. THE HIVE: a multidisciplinary approach to medical education. Eur J Anat. 2021;25(1):101-6.

Taba JV, Cortez VS, Moraes WA, Iuamoto LR, Hsing WT, Suzuki MO, et al. The development of laparoscopic skills using virtual reality simulations: A systematic review. PloS One. 2021;16(6):e0252609.

Vilchez-Cavazos JF, Simental-Mendía MA, Peña-Martínez VM, Acosta-Olivo C, Quiroga-Garza A, Elizondo-Omaña RE, et al. Simulador de artroscopia de rodilla para desarrollar habilidades artroscópicas en los residentes de ortopedia y traumatología. Orthotips. 2022.

Sutherland LM, Middleton PF, Anthony A, Hamdorf J, Cregan P, Scott D, Maddern GJ. Surgical simulation: a systematic review. Ann Surg. 2006;243(3):291-300.

Sarker SK, Patel B. Simulation and surgical training. Int J Clin Pract. 2007;61(12):2120-5.

Waran V, Narayanan V, Karuppiah R, Pancharatnam D, Chandran H, Raman R, Rahman ZA, Owen SL, Aziz TZ. Injecting realism in surgical training-initial simulation experience with custom 3D models. J Surg Educ. 2014;71(2):193-7.

Snyderman CH, Gardner PA, Lanisnik B, Ravnik J. Surgical telementoring: A new model for surgical training. The Laryngoscope. 2016;126(6):1334-8.

Gilbody J, Prasthofer SW, Ho K, Costa ML. The use and effectiveness of cadaveric workshops in higher surgical training: a systematic review. Ann Royal Coll Surgeons England. 2011;93(5):347-52.

Macchi V, Porzionato A, Stecco C, Tiengo C, Parenti A, Cestrone A, De Caro R. Body parts removed during surgery: a useful training source. Anatomical Sciences Education. 2011;4(3):151-6.

Robles-Torres JI, Zapata-González JA, Lozano-Salinas JF, Montelongo- Rodríguez FA, Elizondo-Omaña RE, Guzman-Lopez S, et al. A Novel Cadaveric Training Model for Percutaneous Renal Access. Bol Col Mex Urol. 2022.

McLachlan JC. New path for teaching anatomy: living anatomy and medical imaging vs. dissection. Anatomical record. Part B, New Anatomist. 2004;281(1):4-5.

Garment A, Lederer S, Rogers N, Boult L. Let the dead teach the living: the rise of body bequeathal in 20th-century America. Academic Medicine. 2007;82(10):1000-5.

Riederer BM. Body donations today and tomorrow: What is best practice and why? Clinical Anatomy (New York, N.Y.). 2016;29(1):11-8.

Habicht JL, Kiessling C, Winkelmann A. Bodies for Anatomy Education in Medical Schools: An Overview of the Sources of Cadavers Worldwide. Acad Med. 2018;93(9):1293-300.

Aggarwal R, Boza C, Hance J, Leong J, Lacy A, Darzi A. Skills acquisition for laparoscopic gastric bypass in the training laboratory: an innovative approach. Obes Surg. 2007;17(1):19-27.

Kobayashi E, Hishikawa S, Teratani T, Lefor AT. The pig as a model for translational research: overview of porcine animal models at Jichi Medical University. Transplant Res. 2012;1(1):8.

Zemanova MA, Knight A. The Educational Efficacy of Humane Teaching Methods: A Systematic Review of the Evidence. Animals (Basel). 2021;11(1):114.

Gaitanidis A, Simopoulos C, Pitiakoudis M. What to consider when designing a laparoscopic colorectal training curriculum: a review of the literature. Tech Coloproctol. 2018;22(3):151-60.

Botden SM, Christie L, Goossens R, Jakimowicz JJ. Training for laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication with a newly designed model: a replacement for animal tissue models? Surgical Endoscopy. 2010;24(12):3134-40.

Suguita FY, Essu FF, Oliveira LT, Iuamoto LR, Kato JM, Torsani MB, Franco AS, Meyer A, Andraus W. Learning curve takes 65 repetitions of totally extraperitoneal laparoscopy on inguinal hernias for reduction of operating time and complications. Surg Endosc. 2017;31(10):3939-45.

Grantcharov TP, Kristiansen VB, Bendix J, Bardram L, Rosenberg J, Funch-Jensen P. Randomized clinical trial of virtual reality simulation for laparoscopic skills training. Br J Surg. 2004;91(2):146-50.

Gurusamy KS, Aggarwal R, Palanivelu L, Davidson BR. Virtual reality training for surgical trainees in laparoscopic surgery. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2009;(1):CD006575.

Rapp AK, Healy MG, Charlton ME, Keith JN, Rosenbaum ME, Kapadia MR. YouTube is the Most Frequently Used Educational Video Source for Surgical Preparation. J Surg Educ. 2016;73(6):1072-6.

Yee A, Padovano WM, Fox IK, Hill EJR, Rowe AG, Brunt LM, Moore AM, Snyder-Warwick AK, Kahn LC, Wood MD, Coert JH, Mackinnon SE. Video-based Learning in Surgery: Establishing Surgeon Engagement and Utilization of Variable-duration Videos. Ann Surg. 2020;272(6):1012-9.

Rodriguez HA, Young MT, Jackson HT, Oelschlager BK, Wright AS. Viewer discretion advised: is YouTube a friend or foe in surgical education? Surg Endosc. 2018;32(4):1724-8.

de'Angelis N, Gavriilidis P, Martínez-Pérez A, Genova P, Notarnicola M, Reitano E, et al. Educational value of surgical videos on YouTube: quality assessment of laparoscopic appendectomy videos by senior surgeons vs. novice trainees. World J Emerg Surg. 2019;14:22.

Jackson HT, Hung CS, Potarazu D, Habboosh N, DeAngelis EJ, Amdur RL, Estroff JM, Quintana MT, Lin P, Vaziri K, Lee J. Attending guidance advised: educational quality of surgical videos on YouTube. Surg Endosc. 2021.

Celentano V, Smart N, McGrath J, Cahill RA, Spinelli A, Obermair A, et al. LAP-VEGaS Practice Guidelines for Reporting of Educational Videos in Laparoscopic Surgery: A Joint Trainers and Trainees Consensus Statement. Ann Surg. 2018;268(6):920-6.

Sakamoto Y, Okamoto S, Shimizu K, Araki Y, Hirakawa A, Wakabayashi T. Hands-on Simulation versus Traditional Video-learning in Teaching Microsurgery Technique. Neurologia medico-chirurgica. 2017;57(5):238-45.

Clifton W, Damon A, Nottmeier E, Pichelmann M. The importance of teaching clinical anatomy in surgical skills education: Spare the patient, use a sim! Clin Anat. 2020;33(1):124-7.

Dee EC, Alty IG, Agolia JP, Torres-Quinones C, van Houten T, Stearns DA, et al. A Surgical View of Anatomy: Perspectives from Students and Instructors. Anatomical Sciences Education. 2021;14(1):110-6.

Huri G, Gülşen MR, Karmış EB, Karagüven D. Cadaver versus simulator based arthroscopic training in shoulder surgery. Turkish J Med Sci. 2021;51(3):1179-90.

Tan SS, Sarker SK. Simulation in surgery: a review. Scottish Med J. 2011;56(2):104-9.

Walliczek-Dworschak U, Schmitt M, Dworschak P, Diogo I, Ecke A, Mandapathil M, Teymoortash A, et al. The effect of different training exercises on the performance outcome on the da Vinci Skills Simulator. Surg Endosc. 2017;31(6):2397-405.

Jokinen E, Mikkola TS, Härkki P. Simulator training and residents' first laparoscopic hysterectomy: a randomized controlled trial. Surg Endosc. 2020;34(11):4874-82.

Tosam MJ, Chi PC, Munung NS, Oukem-Boyer O, Tangwa GB. Global health inequalities and the need for solidarity: a view from the Global South. Developing World Bioethics. 2018;18(3):241-9.

Quiroga-Garza A, Garza-Cisneros AN, Elizondo-Omaña RE, Vilchez-Cavazos JF, Montes-de-Oca-Luna R, Villarreal-Silva EE, Guzman-Lopez S, et al. Research Barriers in the Global South: Mexico. J Global Health. 2022;12:03032.

Raja AJ, Levin AV. Challenges of teaching surgery: ethical framework. World J Surg. 2003;27(8): 948-51.

Tapia-Nañez M, Quiroga-Garza A, Guerrero-Mendivil FD, Salinas-Alvarez Y, Jacobo-Baca G, De la Fuente-Villarreal D, et al. A review of the importance of research in Anatomy, an evidence-based science. Eur J Anat. 2022. 26;4.

Graafland M, Schraagen JM, Schijven MP. Systematic review of serious games for medical education and surgical skills training. Br J Surg. 2012;99(10):1322-30.